Showing posts with label Cookies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cookies. Show all posts

Sunday, July 23, 2023

LEMON CORN MEAL COOKIES from Sobeys


This recipe comes from Sobeys. I made half, omitting cranberries and got 19 1 T. dough balls. They baked in 8.5 minutes. The amount of lemon zest, 1/2 T., is perfect. I doubled the salt to 1/4 t. and it's perfect. You can barely taste the corn meal which is fine with me, but you can definitely feel it in your mouth. I do like that these have a small amount of brown sugar in them. The center is chewy and at 8.5 minutes, they're crunchy on the outside.

I give these 4 stars. Those these turned out great, I've had better lemon cookies.

Tuesday, February 14, 2023

BEST EVER SUGAR COOKIES from The Dispatch

These are indeed some of the best sugar cookies I've ever baked. The recipe's from The Dispatch. They're made with equal parts shortening and your choice of butter, margarine, or oil, and I used butter. I made half and added 1/4 c. chopped sweetened dried tart cherries but it wasn't enough. I got 18 dough balls using a 1 T./1.5"diameter cookie scoop. My cold dough baked in exactly 9 minutes in my Brevelle oven. I rolled the dough in sugar too but wish I hadn't because the outside of the cookies is a little too crunchy, so I'll just put sugar on top next time. The outer parts that browned lightly has that particular sugar cookie flavor and these have the right amount of salt and vanilla too.

I give these 5 stars!

Sunday, January 8, 2023

NESTLÉ® TOLL HOUSE CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES from Very Best Baking

 

This comes from Nestlé's offical site, Very Best Baking. I made half using 3/4 c. semi-sweet chocolate chips, 1/2 c. chopped toasted pecans, and got 27 using a 1 T./1.5" diameter cookie scoop. I baked the dough cold straight out of the refridgerator on 350 F, not 375 F, for about 9 minutes. They have decent flavor but I've made three or four other chocolate chip cookie recipes that I like better. 

I give these 4 stars. The true original recipe for this has you add the baking soda to hot water, then add it to the dough.


Thursday, January 5, 2023

CHEWY BROWNIE COOKIES from Hershey's


This ultra moist cookie comes from Hersheyland. They taste OK but are too moist. They're made with shortening and Dutch process cocoa. The edges get a little crispy but if you let them go too far, the edges burn slightly and taste awful. My 1 T. dough balls baked in 7.5 minutes. I made half the recipe and got 19. I added 1/3 c. mini semi-sweet chocolate chips. The dough is sticky and needs to be refrigerated 45 minutes or so before scooping.

I give these 4 stars. 

Monday, November 28, 2022

ON-THE-TRAIL MONSTER COOKIES from Betty Crocker

This cookie is called On-the-trail Monster Cookies. Its been around for at least 20 years. I first had it in the early 2000s, it was in one of those small baking magazines you get in the grocery store check-out line. I hadn't made them in many years so wanted to try them again. I don't normally add chocolate chips so I didn't this time. They're made with butter and shortening. I used a 1 T./1.5" diameter scoop. The flatted dough balls baked in 9 or 9.5 minutes. This is a very good, basic cookie.

The recipe calls for no salt but I added 1/4 t. for half the recipe but it needed more. It says you can use rolled or quick oat so I used quick oats, since that's the type I've always used. 

I give it 5 stars. 


Sunday, November 6, 2022

DAD'S COOKIES from All Recipes

This oatmeal cookie recipe's from All Recipes. It uses equal parts rolled oats and flour. They taste good but I don't like the texture of them. They're sort of hollow inside because of the high amount of rolled oats, which aren't very absorbent. I used equal parts oil and cooled melted butter instead of all oil. I omitted coconut and added chocolate chips. Mine baked in 8 minutes but they need a little less time as these were a bit overcooked. I made half and got 23 cookies using a 1 T./1.5" scoop.

I give these 4 stars and I'd like to try them again using quick oats and all oil, no butter like last time.


Monday, October 3, 2022

LIP-SMACKING LEMON COOKIES

This recipe comes from The Great American Cookie Cookbook. These are slice 'n bake cookies that use lemon juice and zest. I made half and got a 1.75"x7" log that I rolled in yellow sugar, like they did in the cookbook. I got 20 from just half the recipe. They baked in 8.5 minutes, nowhere near the 15 they said it would take. These taste exactly like a lemon bar, which I'm not crazy about anymore. That's the only flavor these have. Take out the lemon and the dough would have no flavor to speak of. The outside is crunchy, the inside slightly soft.

I give these 3 stars for blandness and wouldn't make them again. 


Thursday, June 2, 2022

JAM THUMBPRINT COOKIES from Nana's Best Recipes

This recipe's from Nana's Best Recipes. I made half, which used 4 T. butter and 2 T. shortening. I added 3 T. ground toasted almonds (325 degrees F for 4 minutes) to the batter and used half the amount of vanilla. I used a 1 T./1.5" diameter cookie scoop and got 15 cookies. They baked up to be 2.5" round. I used Smucker's seedless raspberry jam. These baked in my Breville oven in 10 minutes. These are very good. The shortening gives them a slightly crumbly texture on the outside and the sugar they were rolled in gave them a crunch too.

The dough in the photo on the website I got this recipe from looks crumbly but mine wasn't. I weighed out the flour using 120 g per cup and 25 g for half an egg.

I give these 5 stars and will make them again. I've been baking cookies from scratch for over 20 years and this is the first of its kind I've made. For some reason a thumbprint cookie never appealed to me. This is basically a much quicker version of a jam sandwich/linzer cookie and was quick to make and no trouble at all. I don't know how the baked and cooled cookies do in an airtight container because I only bake a few at a time and eat them within a short time of baking them.


Monday, May 16, 2022

JAM-FILLED COOKIES from Better Homes and Gardens

This recipe came out of my mother's old Better Homes and Gardens Homemade Cookies Cook Book and the recipe is posted below. It's a soft dough that's made with all shortening, both types of sugar, and milk. I made just half. I don't care for the dough. It tastes like oatmeal raisin cookie dough minus the raisins and spices and it doesn't suit a filled cookie, IMO. I cut my rounds slightly bigger, about 1.75", topped with less than the 1 teaspoon of jam (I used Smucker's red tart cherry spread) they said to use (it won't hold that much), and I flattened the top piece of dough in my hand with my other hand to make it larger than the piece below it, laid it on top of the jam and pinched the edges together to seal it and the seal held well, no leakage. They baked in 8 minutes. The edges were crunchy but because of the type of dough this is, it didn't harden much like I was hoping. I was hoping for a crunchy cookie, like a sandwich/linzer cookie.

I give these 3 stars. It was easy though time consuming and I wouldn't make again because of the type of dough this produced. 



Sunday, May 15, 2022

DARK CHOCOLATE (AND PEANUT BUTTER) SANDWICH COOKIES from Tablespoon


I made half the recipe and got 20 slices/10 huge sandwich cookies. I unintentionally cut my dough slices too thick and baked them too long but they still turned out great. I made my own peanut butter filling (frosting) for them, not the marshmallow one in the recipe. These are made with Dutch process cocoa powder, hence the 'dark chocolate' in the recipe name. These have a hint of that particular sugar cookie flavor, and butter flavor. Good recipe and I'll make these again. I don't like that the 2" slices turned into 3-3 1/4" slices when cooked so next time I'll make my dough log 1.5", not 2".

I give these 5 stars.



Tuesday, April 26, 2022

THE BEST CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES from The Café Sucre Farine

This recipe comes from The Café Sucre Farine. These aren't anywhere near the "best", in my opinion but they're decent. I give them 4 stars. Still, I wouldn't recommend them or make them again because of the strong butter flavor. I made half, used almost 1 c. mini semi-sweet chocolate chips and got 33 1 T./1.5" diameter dough balls. I used a scant 1/2 t. fine/table salt and it was perfect. I made the mistake of following directions and mixed this up by hand, not by mixer, and it was very hard on my hand and arm, so use a mixer. The dough spreads out properly and mine baked in 8.5 minutes. 

I give these 3 stars.

Tuesday, March 1, 2022

THE BEST OATMEAL RAISIN COOKIES from Modern Honey

This comes from Modern Honey. I made half and they taste great....because I added double the salt. I used half the amount of vanilla and that's all that was needed. I used half the amount of raisins and added 1/2 c. chopped, toasted pecans. I got 29 1 T./1.5" diameter dough balls. My dough sat out 30 minutes before baking and they didn't spread as much as the ones on the website even though I baked them at a lower temperature, 350 F, which should have caused them to possibly spread a little more.

I have a bone to pick with the recipe creator. Most recipes use room temperature unsalted butter and she didn't say which type to use and if it should be at room temperature. Someone left her a comment asking if they could use unsalted butter instead of salted, as if the recipe originally stated to use salted. As it's written today, she doesn't specify. And her tip to plump up dried raisins, such as ones hard from being frozen or refrigerated, has you soaking them in hot water for too long. You only need to soak them in hot water for 3-5 minutes, then drain and blot dry.

I don't know how to grade these. Without the extra salt these would have been way too sweet and they're perfectly fine with half the vanilla. And the issue I have with salted vs. unsalted butter, I'd grade that part of the recipe a C/D. I'm not new to baking but for those who are, they'd have been really confused and likely would have just gone with another recipe. I've had issues with two of the three cookie recipes I've made from this site and I'm not comfortable making anything more for it as I don't trust it.

Monday, February 7, 2022

CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES WITH CRISCO from This Is Not Diet Food

 

This recipe is from This Is Not Diet Food. I made half and used equal parts butter flavored shortening and regular. Not a fan of butter flavored shortening. I got 20 1T./1.5" dough balls. I used 1/2 c. mini semi-sweet chocolate chips and 1/2 c. chopped toasted pecans. The first batch was a little overbaked at 10 minutes so the rest got baked for 9 minutes, 45 seconds. 

I give these 4 stars. I'd made them again using plain shortening and less salt because they're too salty.

Sunday, December 26, 2021

DOUBLE CHOCOLATE DROPS from Crisco


This recipe is from Crisco Canada. The cookies use all shortening. I used regular, not butter flavored. I made half the recipe and I used slightly less vanilla than called for. I used 1/2 c. mini semi-sweet chocolate chips. I got 28 1 T./1.5" dough balls. The dough is very soft and you'll need to refrigerate your dough at least 90 minutes before you can scoop it out with a cookie scoop. I waited 60 minutes and the dough stuck a little to the scoop. My cold dough balls baked in 9 minutes. They spread out nicely and I've got no complaints other than they need a pinch more salt. The recipe said for rounded tablespoons of dough, bake 10-11 but mine weren't rounded and took only 9. At 9 minutes, even after cooling, they're crunchy on the outside and chewy on the inside. 30 seconds more they'd have been crunchy (overcooked) throughout. 

I give these 5 stars.

Thursday, December 9, 2021

SPRITZ COOKIES from Pillsbury


This recipe gets 1 star from me. It comes from Pillsbury. Spritz cookies use a cookie press. The dough's not supposed to spread out or puff up much because they'll lose their shape. This dough did all the things it's not supposed to do. The flavor is good. They baked in 6.5 minutes. I added lemon extract in place of almond. I added 1/4 t. vanilla extract too and made just half the recipe. I divided the dough in half and baked half to see how they'd do. I'm not happy that they spread so I made slice 'n bake cookies with the other half of the dough. I baked them 7.5 minutes but that was a little too long. There's no point in baking cute small shapes if they'll bake up differently. A quarter of the full recipe will yield 8 slice 'n bake cookies but I don't know how thickly I cut the slices.


Tuesday, November 30, 2021

SUGAR COOKIES from Grace & Good Eats

This all shortening cookie recipe is from Grace & Good Eats. I made half the recipe. I left out the cinnamon and used slightly over than 1/4 t. pure lemon extract but that was too much. I got 23 1 T. dough balls. I rolled each one in sugar and flattened them slightly. The recipe didn't say to do that but I was scared not to, so I did. The cold dough wasn't real firm so I figure they'd have spread out fine without having flattened them first. I baked them for 7 minutes, 45 seconds. They're crispy on the outside and soft in the middle. The ones pictured were baked for 8 minutes.

I give these 4 stars for appearance and texture but they don't have a lot of flavor.


Tuesday, November 23, 2021

ULTIMATE DOUBLE CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES from The Flavor Blender


This recipe is from The Flavor Blender. I like that these use melted butter and Dutch-processed cocoa. I made 1/4 of the recipe, added 1/3 c. peanut butter chips (they could have used more) instead of regular chocolate chips, and an extra 1/8 t. salt, and got 13 1 T./1.5" dough balls. My cool dough (66 degrees F) baked in 9 minutes. The cookies puffed while baking then flattened when cooling. These taste good but I can taste the butter a little more than I like.

I give these 4 stars but wouldn't make them again because I've made several others that taste better.

Monday, September 20, 2021

"PERFECTLY CHOCOLATE" CHOCOLATE CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES from Hershey's

This comes from Hershey's. I don't care for them. Mine didn't spread out quite like the ones in the photo and were slightly puffy. They're buttery and flavorwise remind me of a brownie. I made half the recipe and used 1/2 c. semi-sweet chocolate chips and got 23 1 T./1.5" dough balls. They baked in 9 minutes.

I give these 3 stars.

Thursday, July 8, 2021

BEST CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES from Dear Crissy

These come from Dear Crissy and they're far from the 'best' chocolate chip cookie. They're very very basic in flavor and I wouldn't make them again. They do spread out nicely and that's about all I can say about them. I made half using 3/4 c. chocolate chips and got 22 1 T./1.5" dough balls. I let my cold dough balls sit at room temperature for 30 minutes and they baked in just under 8 minutes. 

I rate these 3 stars.


Thursday, May 6, 2021

DOUBLE CHOCOLATE OATMEAL CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES from Mel's Kitchen Café

This come from Mel's Kitchen Café and they're awful. The dough has zero flavor. Literally the only flavor comes from the chocolate chips. I made half and got 26 1 T. dough balls. I used 1/2 c. semi-sweet chocolate chips. I doubled the vanilla and you can't even taste it. I used 1/8 t. more salt and it still needs more. Huge disappointment!

I grade these an F.